P15040coll4 59
P15040coll4 59
18-16
NO. 18-16 APR 2018
[Link]
[Link]
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Foreword
Today’s operational environment presents threats the Army has not faced
in nearly 20 years. Against peer competitors, the joint force may face air
parity or even localized enemy air overmatch, challenging the assumption
of air superiority the joint force has held since the Korean War. This will
make maneuver forces vulnerable to air attack by fixed- and rotary-wing
aircraft, unmanned aircraft systems, and cruise missiles. Maneuver forces
lack capacity and capability to address these threats and the Army requires a
speedy response.
The Chief of Staff of the Army directed the Army to execute a plan to
increase short-range air defense (SHORAD) capability. The immediate
solution is to train and arm teams of Soldiers organic to select brigade
combat teams with Stinger missiles. This directive is one line of effort as the
force structure for a dedicated maneuver SHORAD capability increases.
Stinger missiles provide a key capability for maneuver forces to defend
themselves from aerial observation and attack. However, without direct
involvement from senior brigade combat team leaders and effective leader
training, these missiles will become dead weight at best or a fratricide in
waiting at worst. Units must plan effectively to utilize this capability and
ensure it ties directly to their scheme of maneuver as opposed to simply
task-organizing one Stinger team per company.
This guide is designed as a single entry point for brigade combat team and
maneuver battalion commanders and their staffs to effectively train and
fight Stinger teams as part of an integrated combined arms team. These
planning and employment techniques should prove invaluable to effectively
maximize mission effectiveness, allow maneuver forces to retain the
initiative, and provide freedom of maneuver from the air.
Randall A. McIntire
Brigadier General, USA
Commandant
iii
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Special thanks to the Fires CoE and TCM ADA BDE for their contributions.
The Secretary of the Army has determined that the publication of this
periodical is necessary in the transaction of the public business as required
by law of the Department.
Unless otherwise stated, whenever the masculine or feminine gender is
used, both are intended.
Note: Any publications (other than CALL publications) referenced in
this product, such as ARs, ADPs, ADRPs, ATPs, FMs, and TMs, must be
obtained through your pinpoint distribution system.
v
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Introduction
This guide serves as a concise and consolidated tool for leaders to integrate
short-range air defense (SHORAD) into battalion and brigade plans.
The principal audience for this guide is brigade and battalion staffs who
have maneuver Soldiers equipped with Stinger man-portable air defense
systems (MANPADS).
Commanders, staffs, and subordinates must ensure their decisions and
actions comply with applicable U.S., international, and, in some cases,
host-nation laws and regulations. Commanders at all levels must ensure
their Soldiers operate in accordance with the Law of War and the rules of
engagement. (See Field Manual 27-10, The Law of Land Warfare.)
The chapters of this guide first outline general air defense principles and
planning and then focus on air defense within the maneuver brigade combat
team. The appendices focus on training and employment of Stinger teams.
1
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Chapter 1
Air Defense Planning Principles and Guidelines
This chapter provides a general overview of Army air defense planning
principles and guidelines. It addresses the role of air defense, the Army’s
air defense operational elements, air defense employment principles
and guidelines, alert statuses and warnings, and weapon control statuses
(WCSs).
3
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
The decision to engage air threats should include consideration of the unit’s
mission and tactical situation. If the enemy aerial platforms are outside the
engagement range of the unit’s weapons, a unit’s most attractive option may
be to seek cover.
4
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Attack Operations
Attack operations are offensive actions that destroy and disrupt enemy air
and missile capabilities before, during, and after launch. Attack operations
consist of the destruction, disruption, or neutralization of enemy airfields;
aerial airframes; tactical ballistic missile (TBM) launch platforms; logistical
support trains; electronic warfare platforms; reconnaissance, surveillance,
and target acquisition platforms; and any other potential targets that can
be destroyed before having the opportunity to be utilized against friendly
forces. Sensors may be able to identify launch points for attack operations.
Mission Command
Mission command is the exercise of authority and direction by the
commander using mission orders to enable disciplined initiative within the
commander’s intent to empower agile and adaptive leaders in the conduct
of unified land operations (Army Doctrine Publication [ADP] 6-0, Mission
Command).
Mission command is the baseline that links active air and missile defense,
passive defense, and attack operations to provide timely assessment of the
threat, and rapid dissemination of tactical warning, mission assignment,
targeting data, and post-strike assessment.
Components of SHORAD
The Stinger missile system is a man-portable air defense system
(MANPADS). It is a shoulder-fired, infrared radiation-homing, heat-
seeking, negative ultraviolet-guided missile system which requires no
control from the gunner after firing. Stinger has an identification, friend-
or-foe (IFF) subsystem that aids the gunner and team chief in identifying
friendly aircraft. Stinger provides SHORAD for units and select critical
assets. The Stinger weapon system is designed to counter low-level, fixed-
and rotary-wing aircraft, and unmanned aircraft (unmanned aircraft system
groups 3-4). (See Army Techniques Publication [ATP] 3-01.18, Stinger
Team Techniques [CAC login required for access.])
5
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
6
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
7
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Employment Guidelines
Planning during defense design and positioning ADA units involves
applying six employment guidelines. Defense planners apply these
guidelines vertically and horizontally to account for the variety of altitudes
and ingress routes from which the enemy can attack or conduct intelligence,
surveillance, and reconnaissance operations.
Mutual Support
Position weapons so the fires of one weapon can engage targets within
the dead zone of the adjacent weapon systems. For gun systems, this dead
zone is usually small. For missile systems, the dead zone may be large and
mutual support is a critical element. Mutual support can also cover non-
operational units or units at lower states of readiness.
Overlapping Fires
Position weapons so their engagement envelopes overlap. Because of the
many altitudes from which the enemy can attack or conduct surveillance
operations, defense planners must apply mutual, supporting, and
overlapping fires vertically and horizontally. Overlapping fires should be
achieved at a minimum during defense design.
Balanced Fires
Position weapons to deliver an equal volume of fires in all directions. This
is necessary for AMD in an area where the terrain does not canalize the
threat or when the avenues of approach are unpredictable. It is a desired
characteristic of defense design.
Weighted Coverage
Concentrate weapons coverage toward the most likely threat air avenues
of approach or direction of attack. Based on the tactical situation, a
commander may risk leaving one direction of attack unprotected or lightly
protected to weight coverage toward another direction.
Early Engagement
Sensors and weapons are positioned so they can engage the threat before
ordnance release or friendly target acquisition. Early engagements enable
destruction of enemy platforms over enemy forces and unoccupied areas,
thereby reducing the possibility of friendly collateral damage and fratricide.
8
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Defense-In-Depth
Position the sensors and weapons in depth to expose the threat to a
continuously increasing volume of fire as it approaches the friendly
protected asset or force. Defense-in-depth decreases the probability that
attacking missiles, aircraft, rockets, artillery, and mortars will reach the
defended asset or force.
9
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Positive Control
AMD fires are controlled through positive or procedural ROE. Positive
control is a method that relies on positive identification and tracking of
airborne objects and control of fires within an airspace conducted by
an agency having the authority and responsibility therein. A common
operational picture that synthesizes data from multi-Service intelligence and
air defense sensors can correlate air tracks and identify them based on an
integrated airspace control plan and established identification criteria that
enables positive control. Positive control is exercised through fire control
orders.
Procedural Control
Procedural control is a method that relies on a combination of previously
agreed upon and promulgated orders and procedures. Procedural controls
include air defense warnings (ADWs), ROE, airspace control orders,
published identification criteria, and WCS.
Air Defense Warnings
ADWs state the probability of an air raid based on the threat assessment
and current intelligence preparation of the battlefield. The area air defense
commander (AADC) establishes the baseline ADW during the planning
phase for the joint force. The ADW may be different for an air breathing
threat and a missile threat. Subordinate air defense commanders may
issue higher, but not lower, ADW for their region or sector. ADWs are
disseminated though mission command channels to air and missile defense
elements and fire units.
10
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Lookout. Aircraft or missiles are in the area of interest but are not
yet threatening or are inbound but there is time to react. As a general
rule, a lookout status should be assumed when an air threat is within
30 kilometers of the division or BCT area of operations.
Snowman. No aircraft or missiles pose a threat at this time. Aircraft
and missiles are monitored but not broadcast over the early warning
net.
LADWs are used to alert the force to impending attack at the local level.
They should be incorporated into the local tactical standard operating
procedure (TSOP), explaining what response the supported force desires
when a LADW is broadcast. For example, in the TSOP, when dynamite
precedes an early warning message, the forces stop to increase passive air
defense measures and predesignated elements prepare to engage with a
combined arms response. The response desired by the supported force is
unique to the mission; dependent on mission, enemy, terrain and weather,
troops and support available-time available and civil considerations
(METT-TC); and should be included in the supported force’s TSOP. LADW
dissemination must be rehearsed with the supported force.
Rules of Engagement
ROE are positive and procedural management directives that specify the
circumstances and limitations under which forces will initiate or continue
combat engagement with enemy forces. (See Unified Command Policy
2011, Executive Office of the President [04/08/2011].) The joint force
commander approves the theater ROE. These established rules enable the
AADC to retain control of the air battle by prescribing the exact conditions
under which engagements may take place. ROE apply to all warfare
participants in theater and are disseminated to all echelons of air, land, and
sea forces. There are seven ROE categories:
•• Right of self-defense
•• Identification criteria
•• Fire control orders
•• WCS
•• Levels of control
•• Modes of control
•• Autonomous operations
11
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Right of Self-Defense
Commanders at all echelons must take the action necessary to protect their
forces and equipment against air or missile attack. When under attack, the
right of self-defense is inherent to all ROE and weapon control procedures
(JP 3-01). When applied to air defense, the right of self-defense includes the
defense of the defended assets.
Identification Criteria
The employment of Army AMD weapon systems requires early
identification of friendly, neutral, or hostile aircraft and missiles to
maximize beyond-visual-range engagement and avoid fratricide. This
requires a clear understanding of the ROE. The problem of distinguishing
friendly, neutral, and enemy aerial objects, while employing various weapon
systems against the enemy, is a highly complex task for some threats. The
AADC and the airspace control authority establish procedures within the
airspace control system to positively identify all airborne assets and permit
AMD. AMD measures reduce delays in operations and prevent fratricide.
Positive identification of tracks is normally the preferred method of
operation. In the absence of positive identification, procedural identification
is used. Procedural identification employs previously established and
promulgated airspace coordinating measures and rules. Procedural
identification separates airspace users by geography, altitude, heading,
time, and/or maneuver. Generally, a combination of positive and procedural
identification is used.
Hostile criteria are basic rules that assist in the identification of friendly
or hostile air platforms, fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft, cruise missiles,
and unmanned aircraft systems. These rules are disseminated by the
commanders of unified commands and by other appropriate commanders
when authorized.
Echelons having identification authority use hostile criteria to determine
the identification of detected air targets. The highest echelon capable of
managing engagement operations normally retains identification authority.
Upon target detection, fire units with near real-time data transmission
capability assist the controlling authority by forwarding target information.
The controlling authority makes final targeting decisions based on
identification (e.g., classification and kinematic evaluation) and delegates
engagement authority. Delegation of controlling and identifying authority
to lower echelons is normal for ADA units and as such, units have both
identification and engagement authority.
12
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
13
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
14
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Modes of Control
There are three modes of control: centralized, decentralized, and
autonomous. The mode of control selected depends on the capabilities of
the communications system, the weapon systems employed, and the friendly
and enemy air situations. The AADC’s area air defense plan specifies the
modes of control, trigger events, when they should be changed, and who has
the authority to change them.
Centralized control mode. In this mode, a higher echelon authority assigns
target engagements to fire units. In some circumstances, fire units seek
permission to engage targets by requesting authorization from that higher air
defense echelon. Centralized control is used to minimize the likelihood of
engaging friendly aircraft while permitting engagements of hostile aircraft
and missiles only when specific orders are issued to initiate the engagement.
This mode would not be appropriate for a Stinger in maneuver units due
to lack of digital communications down to the Stinger team level and the
likelihood the ADAM will not know the exact location of the Stinger teams
to direct which team to shoot which target.
Decentralized control mode. In this mode, the higher echelon monitors
unit actions to make direct target assignments on a management-by-
exception basis to prevent engagement of friendly air platforms and to
prevent simultaneous engagements of hostile air targets. Decentralized
control is used to increase the likelihood that a hostile aircraft or missile
will be engaged as soon as it comes within range of an ADA weapon
system. During operations that are more static, it may be possible for the
ADAM to execute some level of decentralized control over Stinger teams if
their locations are known and direct communication is possible.
Autonomous operations. Autonomous operations occur when a firing unit
has lost all communications (i.e., voice, data link, and tactical chat) to their
higher headquarters. The firing unit commander assumes full responsibility
for control of weapons and engagement of hostile targets in accordance with
existing ROE, WCS, and previously received directives. The team must
take immediate action to reestablish communications. Specific actions taken
will be listed in the unit TSOP or the operation order for the operation.
Normally, the ROE and supplemental fire control measures in effect at the
time of communications loss remain in effect until communications are
regained. Most Stinger teams will operate this way during more dynamic
phases of the battle, as communications with the ADAM and BCT tactical
operations center are likely to be interrupted during this time. The ADAM
cell will not have real-time updates to the positions of the Stinger teams
and therefore would be unable to select a team to conduct an engagement
or decide which team would have line of sight of the threat within the time
frame to engage a fast-moving target.
15
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Vignette 1
An aircraft approached my company position fast and low. The
battalion staff announced a WCS of weapons tight. My gunner acquired
the aircraft, but cannot visually identify it at this time. I direct the
gunner to interrogate. The gunner challenges and receives an unknown
IFF response: beep, beep, beep, beep ...
Action taken: I cannot tell the gunner to engage the aircraft because I
cannot positively identify it as hostile. I do not ignore it, but direct my
gunner to continue tracking the aircraft.
Reason: Weapons tight requires that we make positive hostile
identification before engaging. As the aircraft comes closer, we
positively identify it as an SU-25. It bears enemy national insignia.
Action taken: I order my gunner to engage.
Reason: By visually identifying the aircraft as hostile, I have met the
criteria for engagement under weapons tight.
16
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Vignette 2
At 1230, I received a message from my battalion commander. He
stated, “weapons hold on all jet aircraft flying westbound between 1300
and 1330, weapons tight for all other aircraft.” At 1315, a jet aircraft I
recognize as hostile approaches westbound. It is coming within range
of my gunner’s weapon.
Action taken: I do not direct my gunner to engage but continue to
observe. My gunner tracks the aircraft and waits for my command to
engage. I report the incident to the battalion tactical operations center.
If the aircraft changes its heading so that it is no longer westbound, I
will order my gunner to engage.
Reason: Under weapons hold, I cannot engage except in self-defense.
If the aircraft changes headings, I am then under weapons tight. Since
I have already visually identified the aircraft as hostile, I can then
engage. The aircraft continues on the same heading and fires air-to-
surface missiles at my unit.
Action taken: I order my gunner to engage.
Reason: I have the right to engage any aircraft in self-defense. This
rule applies not only to an attack on my position, but to the unit I am
supporting as well.
17
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Vignette 3
I receive a message from my battalion commander changing the
WCS to weapons free. A jet aircraft approaches my position at a low
altitude and high speed. I direct the gunner to challenge the aircraft on
detection. He receives an unknown audible signal from the IFF.
Action taken: I continue my attempts to visually identify the aircraft
while the gunner goes through the engagement sequence. I cannot
identify the aircraft as friendly, so I order him to engage and then
shoulder my own Stinger.
Reason: I was authorized to order the engagement because weapons
free means I should engage aircraft not positively identified as friendly.
This, coupled with the fact that an unknown audible signal to an IFF
challenge was received and I was unable positively identify the aircraft
as friendly, provided sufficient grounds to launch under weapons free.
(Stinger gunners may not be allowed to engage an unknown target
in weapons free based solely on an IFF decision if constrained by
headquarters, commands directives, or standard operating procedures.)
Had there been other aircraft in the area, the engagement sequence on
the first aircraft would have continued while I directed my attention at
another aircraft. If I had identified the aircraft as friendly after the order
to engage was given but prior to launch, I would have called hold fire.
18
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Chapter 2
Air and Missile Defense
Intelligence Preparation of the Battlefield
Air and missile defense (AMD) intelligence preparation of the battlefield
(IPB) is a four-step systematic continuous process of analyzing the
adversary’s aerial forces and environment in a specific geographic area and
the battlefield around it. By determining the likely adversary courses of
action (COAs) and their associated branches and sequels, and by describing
the environment where AMD forces are operating, the AMD IPB process
helps the commander and staff selectively apply and maximize available
AMD forces at critical points in time and space on the battlefield (Army
Techniques Publication [ATP] 3-01.16, Air and Missile Defense Intelligence
Preparation of the Battlefield). The air defense airspace management
(ADAM) cell in the brigade combat team (BCT) and the AMD cell at
division should work closely with the G-2 or S-2 to develop the AMD IPB.
19
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
20
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
22
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Key terrain. Key terrain is any locality or area in which the seizure,
retention, or control of it will afford a marked advantage to either
combatant. In the aerial dimension, these consist of terrain features that
canalize or constrain air threat systems and terrain with an elevation higher
than the maximum ceiling of air threat systems. Additionally, areas that
can be used for airfields, landing and drop zones, or forward arming and
refueling points also need to be considered as key terrain.
Cover and concealment. Fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft, cruise missiles,
and possibly even UASs will use terrain flying, masking, and ground clutter
to avoid detection and to provide cover from direct fires. Aircraft will also
use the terrain by loitering on reverse slopes, using pop-up tactics, and by
using ground clutter and vegetation as a backdrop to enhance concealment.
Weather analysis. Air operations are especially susceptible to the effects of
weather. Weather analysis for air and missile defense operations is designed
to predict the most likely time over target and other considerations based on
weather effects and light data.
The G-2 or S-2 consider many of the following factors for ground
operations:
•• Visibility has the same effects on visually directed ADA systems and
sensors.
•• High winds adversely affect performance and accuracy of missiles and
UASs.
•• Precipitation affects aircraft, missile, and UAS performance and
reduces the effectiveness of sensors. Cloud cover and ceilings may
restrict operations by setting low operational ceilings, affecting early
warning and restricting visibility and target engagement.
•• Low ceilings, overcast, and cloudy conditions may restrict visually
directed ADA weapons’ detection and acquisition ranges.
•• Extreme temperature and humidity have a severe effect on aircraft and
UASs by decreasing combat range, altitude (particularly rotary-wing
aircraft), and ordnance loads.
23
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
24
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
•• Where do friendly air and missile defense assets fit into the enemy’s
objectives? Do they need to be destroyed or suppressed for the
enemy plan to work? (Answers to these two questions may result in
modification to air avenues of approach.)
•• What are the enemy’s threat characteristics? How are the assets
organized? (Knowledge of enemy organization and who has
operational control will indicate the importance of the AO. For
example, if the enemy’s bombers are at theater level and in the AO,
then that area is probably receiving the theater’s main attack.)
•• Who has tactical control of aircraft at the point of attack?
•• How will UASs be used: attack, reconnaissance, or surveillance? What
are the associated profiles?
•• How does the enemy doctrinally attack? Will the enemy use airborne,
air assault, or special operations forces in conjunction with an air or
ground attack? What sizes are these forces and to what depth are they
used? Will the enemy synchronize the air attack? Does the enemy
have the capability to coordinate an air attack (possibly with varied air
threat platforms that can overmatch friendly air and missile defense
capability)?
•• What are air system combat ingress and egress speeds?
•• What are the doctrinal distances for forward arming and refueling
points? If the enemy’s maximum range falls short of the area of
operations, where is the enemy likely to stop and refuel or be aerial
refueled?
•• How and where will the enemy attack ground targets for interdiction?
•• At what altitude will the enemy approach the target, deliver munitions,
and exit the target area?
•• What is the release authority of certain types of ordnance? (This
is particularly important when dealing with chemical, biological,
radiological, and nuclear [CBRN] threats.)
•• How does the enemy employ reconnaissance assets?
•• How has the enemy historically fought?
•• Was asymmetrical threat operations considered?
25
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
26
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
27
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
*•• Accuracy
*•• Release altitude. How high or low must the aircraft fly?
*•• Reload and fire time. What is the number of missiles
available?
*•• Guidance modes. How does the pilot acquire and engage?
•• UAS. The following should be considered concerning the capabilities
of threat UASs:
○○○ Performances (speed, altitude, and launch restrictions)
○○○ Endurance and range
○○○ Terrain flying or terrain limiting factors
○○○ Target acquisition and standoff range
○○○ Sensor package and payload (maximum weight, type, and load
mixture)
○○○ Loiter time. How long can the UAS stay on station?
○○○ Visibility effects on acquisition
○○○ Modes of recovery and turnaround time
○○○ Real-time, data-link capability
○○○ Guidance modes (ground controlled and preprogrammed)
28
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Group 1: Weigh 20 pounds or less and These systems are generally hand
Micro/Mini normally operate below 1,200 launched (including the hobby-type
feet above ground level at speeds UASs), offer real-time video and
less than 100 knots control, and have small payload
capabilities. They are operated
within the line of sight of the user.
Group 4: Weigh more than 1,320 pounds These relatively large systems
Persistence and normally operate below operate at medium to high
18,000 feet mean sea level at altitudes. This group has extended
any speed range and endurance capabilities
(may require runway for launch
and recovery).
Group 5: Weigh more than 1,320 pounds These systems operate at medium
Penetrating and normally operate below to high altitudes having the greatest
18,000 feet mean sea level at range, endurance, and airspeed.
any speed They require large logistical
footprint similar to that of manned
aircraft.
29
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
30
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Event Template
An event template is a guide for collection and reconnaissance and
surveillance planning. It depicts named areas of interest (NAIs) where the
commander expects to see certain activities of tactical significance and
is used to confirm or deny an enemy COA. These NAIs are based on the
terrain constraints on air approach routes to potential targets and analysis of
the enemy’s attack. The G-2 or S-2 develops an event matrix to support the
event template by providing details on the type of activity expected in each
NAI, the times the NAI is expected to be active, and its relationship to other
events on the battlefield.
Decision Support Template
A decision support template is based on the situation and event templates,
event matrix, and the wargaming of friendly COA results to include the
following:
•• Air avenues of approach
•• Airborne and air assault objectives
•• Landing and drop zones and the largest-sized enemy element that
could be employed at the zone
•• Range of threat systems
•• Range of friendly air and missile defense systems
•• Target areas of interest
•• Decision points
Air target area of interest and decision points are determined in the same
manner as for ground operations. However, due to the high speeds of air
systems, decision points must be placed significantly farther in advance of
the target area of interest.
31
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Chapter 3
Airspace Management
Joint military operations require effective airspace control. The proliferation
of unmanned aircraft systems and fielding of indirect fire platforms capable
of higher altitudes and greater ranges than legacy systems create new
demands on and complicate the airspace control process. Integration and
synchronization of all airspace users are required to establish unity of effort
for effective combat operations.
Airspace Management
Airspace management is the coordination, integration, and regulation of the
use of airspace of defined dimensions (Joint Publication [JP] 3-52, Joint
Airspace Control). Airspace management supports airspace control through
the coordination, integration, and regulation of airspace users by airspace
control elements within an airspace of defined dimensions. (See JP 3-52 for
more discussion on airspace management.)
33
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
34
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
35
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Special Instructions
In some theaters, numerous airspace procedures and airspace usages are
published in the special instructions (SPINS). One section may contain all
the airspace procedures units can expect in an ACP. Other SPINS, such as
tanker procedures or cruise missile procedures, address airspace procedures
within those particular sections. This may include rules of engagement
and combat identification criteria for air defense along with any additional
guidance, directives, or information that weapons system operators and/
or aircrews will be held accountable for (i.e., host-nation restrictions, base
defense zone procedures, and special weapons systems control procedures
(Army Tactical Missile System [ATACMS], unmanned aircraft, Tomahawk
air-launched cruise missile (TALCM)/air-launched cruise missile (ALCM),
etc.). SPINS are published as baseline, weekly, and daily SPINS.
Combined/Joint Area Air Defense Plan
A prioritized list of friendly critical vulnerabilities is developed into a
critical asset list and incorporated into the area air defense plan (AADP).
The defended asset list is the basis of the AADP. Active air defense
operations are designated to protect these selected assets. The AADP
should:
•• Arrange a layered and/or overlapping defense to allow multiple
engagement opportunities.
•• Include information operations strategies for counterair.
•• Contain detailed weapon control and engagement procedures integral
to a joint counterair operation.
•• Specify ACMs.
•• Include all surface-to-air capabilities assigned, attached, and
supporting.
•• Provide for high-value airborne asset protection.
•• Employ electronic warfare to disrupt or destroy guidance systems.
•• Integrate air and space (aircraft), ground (Patriot, short-range air
defense [SHORAD]), and sea-based (AEGIS) capabilities.
36
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
The integration of air defense in the ACP is critical. The location of specific
types of air defense operations and procedures for the identification of
aircraft are critical to a viable ACP. The AADP needs to be written with
detailed engagement procedures that are consistent with the ACP and
operations in the combat zone. Drafters of the AADP must be cognizant
of fielded equipment (and its possible limitations) employed by the joint/
combined forces involved. Airspace control and area air defense operations
need to be capable of functioning in a degraded mission command
environment. Detailed engagement procedures and the roles of subordinate
commanders in decentralized execution of air defense operations are keys to
success in a degraded environment.
Operational Tasking Data Link
The operational tasking data link (OPTASK LINK) lays down specifics
of the data link architecture. The interface control officer (ICO) monitors
the data link nets to ensure transfer and display of critical air defense
information. When directed, the ICO will transmit, via data link,
engagement commands and air defense warning changes to linked agencies.
The ICO coordinates the development of the OPTASK LINK message and
manages all tactical digital information link (TADIL) interfaces to create a
consolidated air picture.
37
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Procedural Control
Procedural control is a method of airspace control that relies on a
combination of previously agreed and promulgated orders and procedures
(JP 3-52). Procedural control should be uncomplicated and understood
by all aircrew members, air traffic control personnel, air defense and fires
weapon system operators, and airspace element personnel. In addition to
air traffic service personnel, the airspace elements in the Army Air Ground
System are organized, trained, and equipped to ensure Army forces can
provide near real-time procedural control and balance airspace control
system requirements with mission command. Near real-time procedural
control pertains to the timeliness of data or information, which has been
delayed by the time required for electronic communication and automatic
data processing. Furthermore, the use of near real-time implies that there are
no significant delays to the process.
39
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Chapter 4
Stinger Plan Development
This chapter describes the Stinger planning process. This chapter also
discusses the requirements of the air defense estimate and air and missile
defense (AMD) inputs for the fires annex. The estimate process assists
the force commander in decision making. The planning process results
in a description of the air defense artillery support for the concept of the
operation.
Overview
AMD planning is a distributed process occurring at all echelons. The area
air defense commander (AADC) at the theater level provides the area air
defense plan. From this plan, the defense designers extract identification
criteria, rules of engagement, airspace coordinating measures, weapon
control statuses (WCSs), air defense warnings (ADWs), self-defense
criteria, and, as applicable, direct the integration of multinational AMD.
The area air defense plan provides a baseline document for planning and is
modified routinely through the publication of air tasking orders, airspace
control orders, and special instructions. The theater area air defense
plan, with the AMD annexes from higher organizations, provides broad
guidelines to develop a Stinger air defense plan at the maneuver brigade
combat team (BCT) or battalion level.
41
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Mission Analysis
The products developed by the staff during mission analysis help
commanders understand the situation and develop the commander’s
visualization. Analyzing the contents of the higher headquarters products
and AMD intelligence preparation of the battlefield (IPB) help with the
following:
•• Identify specified, implied, and essential tasks.
•• Review available assets.
•• Determine constraints and limitations.
•• Identify facts and develop assumptions.
•• Begin risk assessment.
•• Develop commander’s critical information requirements (CCIRs) and
essential elements of friendly information (EEFIs).
•• Develop the initial information collection plan.
Intelligence Preparation of the Battlefield Process
The commander uses IPB to understand the operational environment and
the options it presents to friendly and enemy forces. IPB is a systematic,
continuous process of analyzing the threat and environment in a specific
area. By applying the IPB process, the commander gains the information
necessary to selectively apply and maximize combat power at critical points
in time and space on the battlefield. Airspace — or the aerial dimension
— is the most dynamic and fast paced of the operational dimensions. The
intelligence staff must consider the aspects of air operations and be aware of
the capabilities of air threats to include unmanned aircraft systems (UASs),
ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, air-to-surface missiles, and rotary- and
fixed-wing aircraft. The S-2 has overall staff responsibility for IPB. Air
defense artillery and aviation officers must provide input to the S-2 when
integrating air aspects into the IPB process. As described in Chapter 2, the
IPB process has the following four steps:
•• Define the operational environment.
•• Describe the operational environments’ effects.
•• Evaluate the threat.
•• Determine threat courses of action.
42
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
By the end of the IPB process, the commander expects the staff to have
formulated enemy air avenues of approach (AAA), enemy courses of action
(COAs), and have begun determining the air defense priorities (criticality,
vulnerability, threat [CVT] analysis). See Chapter 2 for a full discussion of
AMD IPB.
Available Assets
Air defense requirements are likely to outstrip forces available, forcing
commanders to make decisions about command and support relationships
for air defense assets. For example, attaching Stinger teams to each
maneuver company risks spreading these assets too thin and makes an
inflexible plan. It is better to keep the teams as general support to a brigade
so the air defense they provide can more easily change by phase of the
operation.
Risk Assessment
During selection of a COA, the commander will face inherent risks (for
example, combining and concentrating weapons’ coverage [engagement
area] toward the most likely enemy AAAs or direction of attack to achieve
weighted coverage). Based on the tactical situation, a commander may
risk leaving one direction of attack unprotected or lightly protected to
weight coverage toward another direction. Conducting a risk assessment is
recommended before this guideline is implemented.
43
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
44
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
45
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
46
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
47
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Planners across the staff need a unit airspace plan. This plan promotes
the permissive use of surface-to-surface, air-to-surface, and surface-to-air
fires. Flight routes and SHORAD engagement zones in particular promote
effective surface-to-air fires and minimize fratricide. Brief the unit airspace
plan during the combined arms rehearsal. Contact and correct any airspace
users who do not fly in compliance with the unit airspace plan. The BCT
does not allow adjacent units to conduct uncontrolled movement across unit
boundaries. The same rule applies to air boundaries.
48
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
49
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
50
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
51
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
52
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
53
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
H+10 to H+24
18. Rehearse movement to an alternate position.
19. Check night vision goggles.
20. Establish sleep, security, and preventive maintenance checks and
services plan.
21. Check position camouflage.
D+1 and beyond
22. Constantly improve primary and alternate positions and construct
range cards.
Types of Positions
Primary. A position from which the fire unit intends to accomplish its
tactical mission. This is the best location available in the designated area for
the Stinger/Avenger team to accomplish the mission.
Alternate. A position to which the fire unit moves when the primary
position becomes compromised or unsuitable for carrying out the assigned
mission. The alternate position must be far enough away to prevent it
being rendered compromised by the same action that affected the primary
position. The alternate position must meet all the requirements of the
primary position.
Supplementary. A place to fight which provides the best means to
accomplish a task or cover an AAA that cannot be accomplished from the
primary or alternate positions.
Hasty. A position selected with no prior reconnaissance.
Exercise care to avoid placing positions near terrain features easily
recognized from the air. Positions are more vulnerable to enemy fires once
spotted near an identifiable object.
Stinger Position Checklist
Location:
•• Within 100 meters of the grid given in the OPORD.
•• Received permission to adjust location.
•• Within 100 meters of the grid reported to higher command.
•• Position away from terrain features that are easily recognized from the
air.
54
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Security:
•• Approaching vehicle halted away from position.
•• Challenge and password used correctly.
•• Local security maintained.
•• Soldiers in the proper uniform.
•• Maintain light, noise, and litter discipline.
•• Supplementary positions created.
•• Dummy positions created.
Threat:
•• Show air avenues of approach on the map.
•• Show direction of the highest air threat in relation to the position on
the ground.
•• Show on the map where the last enemy aircraft was encountered.
•• Position away from terrain features easily recognized from the air.
•• Show forward line of own troops on the map.
Sector of fire:
•• Is the primary target line the same given in the OPORD?
•• Has permission been received to adjust the primary target line?
•• Are limits designated as in the OPORD?
•• Are there major obstructions in the sector of fire?
•• Is sector of fire limited or is there 360 degrees of coverage?
Cover and concealment:
•• Is the vehicle camouflaged?
•• Is the vehicle concealed?
•• Are the vehicle tracks into position concealed?
•• Is all the equipment camouflaged and concealed?
55
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Access:
•• Are there adequate routes in and out of position?
•• Is there more than one route?
•• Is the vehicle combat parked?
Alternate position:
•• Is it 200-300 meters away from the primary?
•• Does it have a quick concealed access route?
•• Does it cover the same sector of fire?
•• Does it have a hasty command post position?
•• Does it have a deliberate command post position?
Deliberate fighting position:
•• Are there hasty fighting positions?
•• Is there a deliberate fighting position?
•• Are there 18 inches of overhead cover?
•• Is the range card complete?
•• Magnetic north.
•• Sector of fire limits.
•• Eight-digit grid coordinate.
•• Range rings to maximize range of Stinger nearby positions.
•• Any defensive measures or obstacles.
•• ADW/WCS.
•• Enemy threat information.
•• Is there a position:
○○○ In the defense plan?
○○○ For evacuation by vehicle?
○○○ For evacuation by foot?
•• Has an ammunition storage area been designated?
56
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Vehicle:
•• Is the dispatch complete and correct?
•• Is the daily preventive maintenance checks and services on vehicle,
communications, and other items complete?
Soldiers:
•• Know the task force and platoon mission.
•• What air defense fire units are adjacent to your position?
•• What other friendly units are adjacent to your position?
•• What is the ADW/WCS and at what effective time?
•• What are the rules of engagement for ground and air?
Readiness Conditions
Readiness conditions (REDCONs) describe the degree of readiness of
teams. The decision to select a REDCON is based on intelligence, early
warning, and ADW. Normally, the BCT will designate the readiness
condition used by subordinate Stinger teams. Additionally, readiness
conditions are used to ready the force in a logical way for action against
the enemy while retaining the ability to stand down teams for rest or
maintenance. This is critical with two-man crews and 24-hour capable
systems.
57
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix A
Stinger Characteristics
The Stinger Weapon System
The Stinger weapon system is a man-portable, shoulder-fired, infrared
homing-guided/negative ultraviolet (UV) heat-seeking missile with
modified proportional navigation. It requires no control from the gunner
after firing. The system is equipped with an identification, friend or foe
(IFF) subsystem, which aids the team in identifying friendly aircraft.
Missile Round
The missile round is composed of two major components: the fiberglass
launch tube and the missile.
Launch tube. The launch tube, which houses the missile, provides the main
support for all other parts of the weapon round. Both ends of the launch
tube are sealed with a breakable disk. The front infrared (IR) window is
transparent to IR and UV radiation. Both the front and rear disks break
when the missile is launched. The hinged sight assembly attached to the
launch tube allows the gunner to sight the weapon, determine target range,
super elevate, and hear the audible tones through the acquisition indicators.
Missile. The Stinger missile consists of three sections: guidance, warhead,
and propulsion sections.
•• The guidance assembly processes target IR and UV radiation. It
provides guidance commands for the missile during flight. The seeker
tracks the IR/negative UV source automatically after the gyro is
uncaged and during missile flight. The control assembly converts the
guidance commands into movement of control surfaces that direct the
flight of the missile.
•• The warhead section consists of a fuse assembly and a quantity of
explosives, housed within a cylindrical case. The fuse can detonate the
warhead in three ways: by means of a low-impact switch, a hard target
sensor, or by self-destructing. Should a target intercept not occur, a
self-destruct circuit detonates the warhead.
•• A separable launch motor and a dual thrust flight motor provide
propulsion for the missile. The launch motor provides initial thrust that
ejects the missile from the launch tube allowing the missile to coast to
a safe distance from the gunner. The flight motor ignites and propels
the missile to the target.
59
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Weapon Round
A weapon round consists of a missile round fitted with a separable
gripstock. The separable, reusable gripstock consists of operational controls,
connectors, latch mechanism, and the IFF antenna assembly. Located on
the gripstock assembly are the safety and actuator device, uncaging switch,
firing trigger, IFF challenge switch, IFF interrogator connector, and battery/
coolant unit (BCU) receptacle. When the IFF antenna assembly is unfolded
and the IFF interrogator is connected to the weapon, it is capable of
interrogating aircraft and receiving coded replies. After a missile launch, the
gripstock is removed from the launch tube.
Ready Round
A ready round consists of the weapon round and a battery coolant unit.
When the battery coolant unit is inserted into the weapon round, it becomes
a ready round. The battery coolant unit is a thermal battery that provides
prelaunch power for the system and argon gas that cools the missile seeker
for a maximum of 45 seconds (ready round). Once activated, the battery
coolant unit must be removed within three minutes of activation to avoid
damage to the gripstock due to excessive overheating. Once activated, the
battery coolant unit is expended and removed from the gripstock.
Identification Friend or Foe Subsystem
The Stinger weapon system is equipped with an IFF subsystem to aid in
the identification of aircraft. The IFF system is an electronic system that
provides an automated means to identify aircraft as friend, possible friend,
or unknown. It does not identify hostile aircraft.
Weapon and Missile Rounds
The Stinger missile is packaged as weapon round complete, weapon round
partial, or missile round. A weapon round complete includes the missile
round, gripstock, and varying numbers of BCUs packaged in a reusable
aluminum container. A weapon round partial contains the missile round and
varying numbers of BCUs packaged in a reusable aluminum container. The
missile round contains the missile round and varying numbers of BCUs
packaged in a fiberboard box within a wire-bound wooden container.
60
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Basic Stinger missile. The basic Stinger is no longer active in the U.S.
inventory.
FIM-92D – Stinger-Reprogrammable Microprocessor (RMP). The
RMP Stinger missile has additional improvements to the guidance system.
These improvements enable the weapon to reject complex infrared
countermeasures (IRCM), provide greater background discrimination than
the basic Stinger, and have made the missile more responsive to steering
commands. The addition of a reprogrammable module allows weapon
updates to meet future threats without the need to modify missile hardware.
FIM-92E – Block I. The Block I Stinger missile has improved guidance
system electronics, including a roll frequency sensor (ring laser gyro). This
upgrade provides the missile with the capability of determining the up
position before and during launch, allowing the missile guidance system
to bias its flight to counteract gravitational forces. The Block I upgrade
enhances missile performance when launched against targets in non-ideal
scenarios, such as minimum target elevation angles and low target aspect
angles in a clutter environment. FIM-92E Block I Stinger missiles only
fly in the Block I mode and have full continental U.S. (CONUS) IRCM
performance if they are launched with a Block I gripstock or platform
launcher.
Table A-1. Weapon round complete configurations
NSN Model No. DODIC BCU Unit Pack Boxed Dimensions
Quantity Weight
61
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
62
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Missile Round 59.5 inches 7.25 inches 7.25 inches *36.1 lbs
(151.1 cm) (18.4 cm) (18.4 cm) (16.4 kg)
IFF Programmer/ 23.6 inches 13.3 inches 10.7 inches 41.0 lbs (18.6 cm)
Battery Charger (59.9 cm) (33.8 cm) (27.2 cm)
Shipping and Storage 66.0 inches 13.5 inches 18.0 inches 54.1 lbs (empty)
Container (167.6 cm) (34.3 cm) (45.7cm) (24.5 kg)
100.0 lbs (full)
Capabilities
•• Supersonic, surface-to-air missile
•• Range: unclassified planning range of four kilometers
•• 2.75 inch diameter
•• 59.5 inch length
•• 36.1 pounds weight
•• Passive guidance with IR/negative UV homing and modified
proportional navigation
•• Warhead: high explosives
•• Rocket motor: solid propellant, two-stage separable launch motor and
dual-thrust flight motor
•• Extreme mobility: Goes everywhere the Soldier can go
63
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
64
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
65
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix B
Stinger Team Certification and Training
Managing Stinger Gunnery and Training in the
Brigade Combat Team
Brigade combat teams (BCTs) will provide Soldiers organic to their
formation to form Stinger teams, with no additional dedicated air defense
Soldiers from the Army at large. Soldiers attending the five-week Stinger
course are awarded an Additional Skill Identifier (ASI) and will have the
basic tools they need to put the Stinger missile into operation. However,
they will have limited capability to conduct sustainment training or
certification on the system without centralized help from the BCT and
outside organizations. Stinger teams should be treated as low-density,
military occupational specialty holders and conduct centralized training.
The following are recommended responsibilities for a gunnery and training
program for these Soldiers:
Brigade
•• Directs consolidated Stinger team sustainment training weekly.
•• Designates the field artillery battalion commander (fire support
coordinator [FSCOORD]) as the commander in charge of the Stinger
gunnery program.
•• The BCT air defense and airspace management (ADAM) cell plans
monthly, quarterly, and semi-annual evaluations and certifications
as per Training Circular (TC) 3-01.18, Stinger Gunnery (CAC login
required for access).
•• Designates a Stinger standardization officer (recommend the
ADAM officer in charge as the air defense artillery [ADA] subject
matter expert). The following are the Stinger standardization officer
responsibilities:
○○○ Reviews and approves written tests for Tables I, III, VII, and VIII.
○○○ Works with the S-2 to create the visual aircraft recognition
(VACR) hot list for study and certification.
○○○ Establishes a centralized training program for the Stinger teams
in the BCT and manages training aids, devices, simulators, and
simulations (TADSS) for the BCT.
○○○ Maintains a list of certified trainers and evaluators.
○○○ Coordinates for outside training and evaluations as necessary.
67
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
68
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
69
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
2 hours VACR II
70
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
71
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
72
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
73
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
74
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
75
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix C
Manual Short-Range Air Defense Control System
Accurate, timely, and reliable early warnings enable air defense artillery
(ADA) fire units to be more effective. Early warning serves two purposes:
alerting and cueing. Alerting information tells the Soldier that an aircraft
is approaching his position or defended asset. Cueing information tells the
Soldier which direction the aircraft is travelling, its positional location, and
its tentative identification in a timely manner. This enables the user to focus
attention in the right direction and detect the aircraft at a greater range. To
obtain this information, short-range air defense (SHORAD) units use a
manual control system that provides alerting, but very limited cueing. The
following are objectives of the Manual SHORAD Control System (MSCS):
•• Provide near real-time transmission of early warning information to
SHORAD and other divisional units.
•• Provide weapon control information to the SHORAD units organic to
the division.
•• Integrate ADA data into the division airspace management effort.
Early warning data is available to any unit that is capable of receiving it.
This includes ADA units, the divisional maneuver units, and combat support
units.
77
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
78
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
79
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
Track Reporting
The track position is reported to 1 kilometer using the coded grid square
in which the aircraft is located and by further subdividing each grid square
into 1 kilometer increments (see the aircraft in Figure C-2). It is located at
SHORAD grid LEMON Three-Three.
Figure C-2
80
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
2. Track Update. To transmit a track update, send only the preface, the
track designator, the new location, and the new heading. Using the example
shown, if the aircraft moves to grid KATIE and is located at KATIE-7-8:
TRACK UPDATE
ALPHA-ZERO-ONE
NOW AT KATIE-SEVEN-EIGHT
HEADING SOUTHWEST
81
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
TRACK UPDATE
ALPHA-ZERO-ONE
NOW AT KATIE-FOUR-THREE
NOW HOSTILE
HEADING SOUTHWEST
SCRUB TRACK
ALPHA-ZERO-ONE
5. Mass Track
The last type of track report is a mass track. A mass track is transmitted
instead of an initial track when the raid size is “many.” When reporting
a mass track, location will normally be one or more 10-kilometer grid
designations. Track updates for a mass track are the same as any other track:
82
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix D
Airspace Control and Coordinating Measures
Coordination measures are used to facilitate planning and efficient
execution of operations while providing safeguards for friendly forces and
noncombatants. See Army Techniques Publication (ATP) 3-52.1, Multi-
Service Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures for Airspace Control, for the
complete list.
83
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
84
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
85
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
86
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
The joint force air component commander (JFACC) can establish an ACA
within the JFACC’s assigned airspace. The JFACC cannot establish an
ACA within another component commander’s assigned airspace without
coordination because this measure could unduly restrict that commander’s
airspace users.
Battle position (BP) and holding area (HA). BPs and HAs are not
categorized as coordination measures, but have implied airspace
components when helicopters use them.
•• A BP is a defensive position from which a unit will fight; it is oriented
on the most likely enemy avenue of approach. A unit assigned a BP
is located within the general outline of the BP, but its maneuver is not
confined to the BP.
•• For attack helicopters, a BP is a maneuvering area containing lateral
and in-depth firing points for the flight to maneuver while searching
for and engaging targets. Because a BP is not a coordination measure,
it does not appear on airspace and fires digital systems as protected
airspace. Planners should use an ACA to establish helicopter BPs. This
protects the aircraft from surface-to-surface fires and other airspace
users. Planners should coordinate size and altitude requirements
based on the mission. Alternatively, planners could use a CAS ROZ to
achieve the same effects as an ACA.
87
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
•• HAs are generically described as areas where ground and air units
await movement instructions, targets, or missions. The area should
be well forward, but it should provide cover and concealment from
enemy observation and fires. Like the BP, HAs are two-dimensional
areas with an implied airspace component, when used by helicopters.
•• Attack helicopters occupy HAs prior to movement to BPs or
individual firing points. While in the HA, the aircraft complete final
coordination with the terminal controller, as required. Because the HA
is not a coordination measure, it does not appear on airspace and fires
digital systems as protected airspace. Planners should use an ACA
to establish helicopter HAs as necessary. This protects the aircraft
from surface-to-surface fires and other airspace users. Alternatively,
planners could use a landing zone ROZ to achieve the same effects as
an ACA.
Kill box. A kill box is a permissive measure with an associated ACM used
to facilitate integrating joint fires and coordinating the airspace within. The
kill box FSCM defines the surface area where friendly forces may employ
surface-to-surface and air-to-surface effects without further coordination.
To facilitate integrating air and surface fires, it is necessary to establish an
ACM over the kill box to protect aircraft from other aircraft and surface-to-
surface fires.
BKB044 JFLCC
ALT 9000-30000FT
160600ZMAY18-
171200ZMAY18
88
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
89
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
LOMEZ
1-7 ADA BN
MIN ALT 500
MAX ALT 3000
240000ZDEC17-
291100ZDEC18
90
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
91
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix E
Topics for Fires and Combined Arms Rehearsals
Brigade combat team (BCT) fires personnel may be involved in several
types of rehearsals. The most common types are combined arms rehearsals
and fires rehearsals. Multiple rehearsals ensure that maximum integration
and synchronization in supporting the scheme of maneuver with fires
is achieved. However, when time is limited, the number and scope of
rehearsals are reduced. In these cases, rehearsals may focus on fires tasks
or particular aspects of the maneuver plan, and the associated fires plan and
air and missile defense appendix. See Army Techniques Publication (ATP)
3-09.42, Fire Support for the Brigade Combat Team, for more information.
93
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
At a minimum for each phase or time period of the operation, the brigade
ADAM cell officer as the senior air defense representative should verify the
following:
•• Weapon control status and air defense warning
•• Rules of engagement to include hostile criteria, friendly criteria, and
unknown response
•• Identification and engagement authority by type of target (fixed wing,
rotary wing, unmanned aircraft system, etc.)
•• Critical assets and defended assets
•• Enemy air and missile threat and capabilities
•• Sensor plan and early warning method
•• Air defense measures
•• The movement plan specifies when and where units will move.
Fires Rehearsals
The fires rehearsal should last no more than 90 minutes and should ensure
the synchronization of the fires effort with the maneuver plan. Fires
rehearsals focus on the execution of air defense tasks, fire support tasks,
the fire support execution matrix, the effectiveness of fire support control
measures, and the timing and synchronization of all fire support efforts with
each other and with the maneuver operation. Fires rehearsals serve to refine
fire support and air defense, ensure understanding by all fires personnel, and
prove the feasibility of executing fires.
A fires rehearsal may be used to prepare for a combined arms rehearsal or
it may be used after a combined arms rehearsal to refine and reinforce key
fires tasks. If the fires rehearsal is held first, changes from the combined
arms rehearsal may require a second fires rehearsal.
At a minimum for each phase or time period of the operation, the brigade
ADAM cell officer as the senior air defense representative should verify the
following:
•• Weapon control status and air defense warning
•• Rules of engagement to include hostile criteria, friendly criteria, and
unknown response
•• Identification and engagement authority by type of target (fixed wing,
rotary wing, unmanned aircraft system, etc.)
94
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
95
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix F
Sample Air and Missile Defense
Appendix to Annex D (Fires)
Annex D (Fires) contains Appendix 7 (Air and Missile Defense [AMD]).
Appendix 7 and associated tabs provide fundamental considerations, format,
and instructions for developing Appendix 7 to Annex D to the base plan or
order. This appendix follows the five-paragraph attachment format.
Sample Appendix 7
Place the classification at the top and bottom of every page of the attachments. Place the
classification marking at the front of each paragraph and subparagraph in parentheses.
Refer to Army Regulation (AR) 380-5 for classification and release marking instructions.
Copy ## of ## copies
Issuing headquarters
Place of issue
Date-time group of signature
Message reference number
a. List maps and charts first. Map entries include series number, country, sheet names
or numbers, edition, and scale.
c. Doctrinal references for this annex include Field Manual (FM) 3-01, U.S. Army
Air and Missile Defense Operations; Army Techniques Publication (ATP) 3-01.18,
Avenger Battalion and Battery Techniques (CAC login required for access);
ATP 3-01.64, Avenger Battalion and Battery Techniques; ATP 3-01.81, Counter-
Unmanned Aircraft System Techniques; ATP 3-01.16, Air and Missile Defense
Intelligence Preparation of the Battlefield; ATP 3-01.8, Techniques for Combined
Arms for Air Defense; and ATP 3-01.50, Air Defense and Airspace Management Cell
Operations.
1. Situation. Include information affecting air and missile defense that paragraph 1 of
the operation plan (OPLAN) or operation order (OPORD) does not cover or that needs
expansion.
97
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
a. Area of Interest. Describe the area of interest as it relates to AMD. Keep in mind
you may need to account for enemy airfields, anticipated forward arming and refuel
points, and ballistic missile operating areas that extend far beyond the area of
operations. Refer to Annex B (Intelligence) as required.
(1) Terrain. Describe the aspects of terrain that impact AMD. Refer to Annex B
(Intelligence) as required. Terrain will canalize low-flying aircraft but also provide
cover from early warning radars and the opportunity for pop-up attacks.
(2) Weather. Describe the aspects of weather that impact AMD. Refer to Annex B
(Intelligence) as required. Low ceilings, precipitation, wind, and night conditions
all have large impacts on how enemy air will operate.
c. Enemy Forces. List known and templated locations and activities of enemy air
threat. List enemy maneuver, indirect fire, and electronic warfare threats that will
impact friendly AMD operations. State expected enemy air threat courses of action
and crosswalk with the map in Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase. Create
Tab B (Enemy Air Order of Battle) and Tab C (Enemy Ballistic Missile Overlay).
Refer to Annex B (Intelligence) as required.
(1) Enemy Ballistic Missiles. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of enemy
ballistic missiles, refer to Tab B (Enemy Air Order of Battle) and Tab C (Enemy
Ballistic Missile Overlay).
(2) Enemy Fixed Wing. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of enemy fixed
wing, refer to Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase, and Tab B (Enemy Air
Order of Battle).
(3) Enemy Rotary Wing. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of enemy
rotary wing, refer to Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase, and Tab B
(Enemy Air Order of Battle).
(4) Enemy Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS). List by group type, discuss
capabilities, limitations, and expected courses of action.
(a) Group 1-2. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of group 1 and 2 UAS,
refer to Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase, and Tab B (Enemy Air
Order of Battle).
(b) Group 3. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of group 3 UAS, refer
to Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase, and Tab B (Enemy Air Order of
Battle).
(c) Group 4-5. Discuss capabilities and courses of action of group 4 and 5 UAS,
refer to Tab A (Air Avenues of Approach) by phase, and Tab B (Enemy Air
Order of Battle).
98
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
(5) Additional Air Threat Information. List air threat information pertinent to
operations but not covered in Annex B (Intelligence). Highlight specific air threat
considerations like sortie rates, subordination of air elements to ground units,
ordinance peculiarities, target preferences, tactics, and recent significant activities.
d. Friendly Forces. See Annex A (Task Organization). Outline the higher headquarters’
air defense plan. List critical asset list (CAL)/defended asset list (DAL) of higher
headquarters in area of interest. Outline the plan, task, and purpose of higher, adjacent,
and other short-range air defense (SHORAD) organizations and assets that support or
impact the issuing headquarters or require coordination and additional support.
2. Mission. State the mission of AMD in support of the base plan or order.
3. Execution.
a. Scheme of AMD. Describe how AMD supports the commander’s intent and concept
of operations. Establish priorities of AMD to units for each phase of the operation. The
scheme of AMD must be concise but specific enough to clearly state what AMD capable
forces are to accomplish in the operation. Utilize the ADA employment guidelines.
The scheme of AMD must answer the “who, what, when, where, and why” of the
AMD to be provided, but provide enough flexibility to allow subordinate commanders
to determine the “how” to the maximum extent possible by ensuring necessary
procedural and positive control. The scheme of AMD may include a general narrative
for the entire operation that should address allocation of assets, support relationships,
task and purpose, positioning guidance and primary target lines for AMD assets. Add
subparagraphs addressing AMD tasks for each phase of the operation use the following
format: task, purpose, execution, and assessment in matrix form. Refer to the base plan
or order and Annex C (Operations) as required.
99
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
b. Execution Matrix.
EVENTS TM 1 TM 2 TM 3 TM 4 TM 5 TM 6
Effective DS Attached
Mission time NLT 170400 NLT 170400 NLT 170400 NLT 170400 NLT 170400
PTL 280 PTL 200 PTL 180 PTL 320 PTL 210
NAI 1 NAI 2
NAI 2 NAI 1
TF 3-8 OBJ O/O Begin O/O Begin O/O Begin O/O Begin O/O Begin
FRANKLIN reorg/ reorg/ reorg/ reorg/ reorg/
consolidation consolidation consolidation consolidation consolidation
c. Early Warning. Review method and format for passing early warning to the entire
force. Consider placement and integration of available early warning assets.
100
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
d. Airspace Planning. Coordinate with the remainder of the Fires staff, aviation, and
other members of the airspace working group to develop the unit airspace plan to
maximize permissive fires, support procedural control of airspace, and minimize
fratricide. The full airspace control plan should be in Appendix 10 to Annex C, but
relevant information can be included here such as coordinating level, SHORAD
engagement zones, and standard Army aircraft flight routes (SAAFRs).
e. Tasks to Subordinate Units. Lists tasks assigned to specific subordinate units not
contained in the base order
(1) Air Defense Warning. Include local air defense warning and the authorities for
both.
(a) Weapon Control Status (WCS). Set by area air defense commander (AADC),
typically at joint level. A different WCS may be selected for different types of
enemy airframes (e.g., fixed wing (FW)/rotary wing (RW)-TIGHT, UAS-FREE.
Include any plans to change WCS.
(b) Hostile Criteria. The AADC will typically disseminate the ROE and hostile
criteria to all ground-based AMD forces through ROE and special instruction
(SPINS). Dropping of flares does not constitute a hostile act. Include preplanned
changes.
(c) Right of Self Defense. The right of commanders to protect their own forces.
When applied to air defense, the right of self-defense includes the defense of the
defended assets.
(e) Level of Control. Level of control describes the ADA echelon at which positive
management of the air battle is conducted. This can be the AADC, regional air
defense commanders, sector air defense commanders, ADA battalion, or individual
fire unit. This is the level that has engagement authority. Different levels of control
may be established for fixed-wing aircraft, rotary-wing aircraft, UASs, and ballistic
missiles. The AADC will specify the level of control in the area air defense plan;
the level of control may likely change over the course of an operation.
101
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
(f) Modes of Control. There are two modes of control: centralized and
decentralized. The mode of control selected will depend on the capabilities of the
communications system, the weapons systems employed, and both the friendly
and enemy air situations. The AADC’s area air defense plan specifies the modes
of control, trigger events and when they should be changed, and who has the
authority to change them. Stinger will most likely operate under decentralized.
(3) Passive Air Defense. Specific passive air defense measures that all units should
take to protect themselves from air and missile attack or surveillance during this
operation. Should include instructions about camouflage, cover, concealment,
dispersion, and hardening. Other examples are moving units at night, noise and light
discipline, and employing obscuration techniques.
(4) Combined Arms for Air Defense. Briefly discuss specific techniques units should
use to help in defending themselves against air or missile attack or surveillance.
4. Sustainment. Identify sustainment priorities for AMD key tasks and specify additional
sustainment instructions as necessary. Describe critical or unusual sustainment actions that
might occur before, during, and after the battle to support the commander’s scheme of AMD.
Refer to Annex F (Sustainment) as required.
a. Logistics. Use subparagraphs to identify priorities and specific instructions for AMD
logistics support. Refer to Annex F (Sustainment) and Annex P (Host-Nation Support)
as required.
(1) Supply. Identify the location of ammunition transfer holding points and
ammunition supply points. Refer to Annex F (Sustainment) as required.
(2) Allocation of Ammunition. List the allocation of machine gun, and missile
ammunition for each phase of the operation based on the amount of Class V
available. Refer to Annex F (Sustainment) as required.
b. Personnel. Use subparagraphs to identify priorities and specific instructions for human
resources support, financial management, legal support, and religious support. Refer to
Annex F (Sustainment) as required.
102
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
c. Health Service Support. Identify ground and air medical evacuation requirements
and the availability, priorities, and instructions for medical care. Refer to Annex F
(Sustainment) as required.
a. Command.
(1) Location of the Commander and Key Leaders. State the location of the
commander and key AMD leaders.
(2) Succession of Command. State the succession of command if not covered in the
unit’s standard operating procedurs (SOPs).
(3) Liaison Requirements. State the AMD liaison requirements not covered in the
base order.
b. Control
(1) Command Posts. Describe the employment of maneuver units and AMD-specific
command posts, including the location of each command post and its time of opening
and closing.
(2) Reports. List AMD-specific reports not covered in standard operating instructions.
Refer to Annex R (Reports) as required. Consider ADA engagement and early
warning reports.
103
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
OFFICIAL:
[Authenticator’s name]
[Authenticator’s position]
Use only if the commander does not sign the original attachment. If the commander
signs the original, no further authentication is required. If the commander does not sign,
the signature of the preparing staff officer requires authentication and only the last name
and rank of the commander appear in the signature block.
DISTRIBUTION: Show only if distributed separately from the base order or higher-level
attachments.
104
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
Appendix G
References
Related Publications
Army Doctrine Reference Publication (ADRP) 3-09, Fires, 31 August 2012.
ATP 3-01.7, Air Defense Artillery Brigade Techniques, 16 March 2016.
ATP 3-01.8, Techniques for Combined Arms for Air Defense, 29 July 2016.
ATP 3-01.16, Air and Missile Defense Intelligence Preparation of the
Battlefield, 31 March 2016.
ATP 3-01.48, Sentinel Techniques, 04 March 2016 (CAC login required for
access).
ATP 3-01.50, Air Defense and Airspace Management (ADAM) Cell
Operation, 05 April 2013.
ATP 3-09.42, Fire Support for the Brigade Combat Team, 01 March 2016.
105
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
106
MANEUVER LEADER’S GUIDE TO STINGER
To help you access information efficiently, the Center for Army Lessons Learned (CALL)
posts publications and other useful products available for download on the CALL website:
[Link]
If your unit has identified lessons or best practices or would like to submit an AAR or a
request for information (RFI), please contact CALL using the following information:
Telephone: DSN 552-9569/9533; Commercial 913-684-9569/9533
Fax: DSN 552-4387; Commercial 913-684-4387
Mailing Address: Center for Army Lessons Learned
ATTN: Chief, Analysis Division
10 Meade Ave., Bldg. 50
Fort Leavenworth, KS 66027-1350
If you would like copies of this publication, please submit your request on the CALL
restricted website (CAC login required):
[Link]
Click on “Request for Publications.” Please fill in all the information, including your unit
name and street address. Please include building number and street for military posts.
NOTE: Some CALL publications are no longer available in print. Digital publications
are available by clicking on “Publications by Type” under the “Resources” tab on the
CALL restricted website, where you can access and download information. CALL also
offers Web-based access to the CALL archives.
CALL produces the following publications on a variety of subjects:
•○○ ○ Handbooks
•○○ ○ Bulletins, Newsletters, and Observation Reports
•○○ ○ Special Studies
•○○ ○ News From the Front
•○○ ○ Training Lessons and Best Practices
•○○ ○ Initial Impressions Reports
[Link]
[Link]
107
CENTER FOR ARMY LESSONS LEARNED
108
NO. 18-XX XXX 2018