Page MenuHomePhabricator

UserInfoCard: Don't use the phrase "articles" when on wikis other than Wikipedias
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

Summary

The CheckUser-UserInfoCard displays the count of created articles. We should change this to the count of all pages on wikis other than Wikipedias.

Background

  • The CheckUser-UserInfoCard displays the count of created articles using "New articles: 123" where "123" is the number of created mainspace pages
    • However, the name for mainspace creations on wikis other than Wikipedias is not "articles".
    • At the same time, using the phrase "New main namespace pages" is quite wordy and we want to avoid the bullet point being too long for the user info card popup that has limited width
    • We could also consider "New content pages" but this may be ambiguous if a wiki considers "content" to be more than just the main namespace pages. For example, the file namespace on Wikimedia Commons would likely be considered "content"
  • The count of articles created is used because the research suggested this as a useful bit of information for determining if a user is editing in good faith
    • This research may have been specific to Wikipedias, and in any case there are wikis like Wikimedia Commons where seeing the number of uploaded files is a better metric
  • On wikis other than Wikipedias we can display the total number of pages created, so that we can use the phrase "New pages"

Acceptance criteria

  • We no longer use the phrase "New articles" to display the number of main namespace creations on non-Wikipedias
  • The "New articles" message has qqq.json documentation to indicate that it would only be used on Wikipedias

Event Timeline

Dreamy_Jazz renamed this task from {component}: {use imperative mood to describe desired outcome} to UserInfoCard: Don't use the phrase "articles" when on wikis other than Wikipedias.Tue, May 20, 12:02 PM
Dreamy_Jazz updated the task description. (Show Details)
Dreamy_Jazz updated the task description. (Show Details)
Dreamy_Jazz updated the task description. (Show Details)

It's not a super-big deal, but I'm wondering:

  • How are you going to identify that it's Wikipedia?
  • Why is there a functionality difference between Wikipedia and other sites? Information about various namespaces can be useful on all sites.
  • Can I read the research?

It's not a super-big deal, but I'm wondering:

  • How are you going to identify that it's Wikipedia?

A configuration variable that is set in operations/mediawiki-config such that wikis in the wikipedia database list use the "New articles" wording and other wikis use "New pages"

  • Why is there a functionality difference between Wikipedia and other sites? Information about various namespaces can be useful on all sites.

We wanted to display the number of new articles based on the research. Specifically it recommended that knowing if a user "Has created a new article" was often a way to see if the user was more likely or less likely to be blocked.

The metric was specific to pages where the namespace was "0".

  • Can I read the research?

Yes. It was published at https://analytics.wikimedia.org/published/reports/account_reputation_score/enwiki_block_rate_variable_analysis_report.html