Cursor Agent can help with this pull request. Just @cursor in comments and I'll start working on changes in this branch.
_{Learn more about Cursor Agents}

@claude review the pr

Claude finished @tonxxd's task —— View job

Code Review Complete ✅

PR #587: Add icon and website url metadata

I've reviewed the implementation of SEP-973 support for icons and website URLs. Overall, the implementation is solid and well-structured. Here's my detailed feedback:

✅ Strengths

1. Well-documented types: The Icon interface in common.ts:18-35 has excellent documentation, including security warnings about URL validation and SVG precautions.

2. Backwards compatible: All new fields (icons, websiteUrl) are optional, ensuring existing code continues to work without changes.

3. Consistent implementation: Icons are added uniformly across all entity types (tools, resources, prompts, server config) with identical patterns.

4. Good UI integration: The IconRenderer component (IconRenderer.tsx:22-68) handles data URIs, URL loading, and error states gracefully with fallback support.

5. Clean type exports: The new Icon type is properly exported through the module hierarchy.

🔍 Issues & Recommendations

1. Type Safety Concerns (High Priority)

Location: mcp-server.ts:179-185, 425-427, 499-502, 616-617, 820

The use of as any type assertions bypasses TypeScript's type checking, which could hide real type mismatches:

// Current approach
this.server = new OfficialMcpServer({
  name: config.name,
  version: config.version,
  icons: config.icons,
  websiteUrl: config.websiteUrl,
} as any);

Recommendation:

• Consider creating temporary interface extensions until the SDK is updated:

interface TemporaryServerConfig extends ServerCapabilities {
  icons?: Icon[];
  websiteUrl?: string;
}

this.server = new OfficialMcpServer({
  name: config.name,
  version: config.version,
  icons: config.icons,
  websiteUrl: config.websiteUrl,
} as TemporaryServerConfig);

• Add a TODO comment with the SDK version to track when these can be removed
• The PR description mentions this is temporary, which is good, but tracking via comments would help

2. Security: Missing URL Validation (High Priority)

Locations:

• common.ts:30 (Icon.src field)
• common.ts:58 (ServerConfig.websiteUrl field)
• IconRenderer.tsx:40-66

The documentation warns that consumers "MUST take steps to ensure URLs are from the same domain or a trusted domain," but there's no validation implemented. This could lead to:

• SSRF attacks if URLs are fetched server-side
• XSS attacks via SVG with embedded JavaScript
• Phishing via malicious websiteUrl links

Recommendations:

1. Add URL validation helper functions:

export function validateIconUrl(url: string, trustedDomains?: string[]): boolean {
  // Validate URL format, check against trusted domains
  // Reject javascript: and data: URIs with scripts
}

2. In IconRenderer.tsx, add CSP-like protections:

// For external URLs, validate domain
// For data URIs, validate MIME type is image/*
// Consider adding sandbox attributes for SVG rendering

3. For websiteUrl in ServerCapabilitiesModal.tsx:137-148, add rel="noopener noreferrer" (✅ already done) and consider warning users about external links.

3. IconRenderer Performance Issue (Medium Priority)

Location: IconRenderer.tsx:34-37

The comment says "For now, just use the first icon" but the sizes field exists specifically to select the best icon:

// Current: always uses first icon
const icon = icons[0];

Recommendation: Implement size-based selection:

function selectBestIcon(icons: Icon[], targetSize: number): Icon {
  // Parse sizes field (e.g., "48x48", "any")
  // Select closest match to targetSize
  // Fall back to first icon if no sizes specified
  return bestMatch || icons[0];
}

This would provide better visual quality and potentially reduce bandwidth for retina displays.

4. Type Casting Inconsistency (Low Priority)

Locations:

• ToolsList.tsx:32 - const toolIcons = (tool as any).icons;
• PromptsList.tsx:32 - const promptIcons = (prompt as any).icons;
• ResourcesList.tsx:65 - const resourceIcons = (resource as any).icons;

These cast to any because the SDK types don't include icons yet, but this pattern is repeated 3 times.

Recommendation: Create a shared helper or type guard:

// In shared/utils.ts
export function getEntityIcons(entity: any): Icon[] | undefined {
  return entity.icons;
}

This centralizes the type assertion and makes it easier to remove once SDK types are updated.

5. Missing Error Handling in IconRenderer (Medium Priority)

Location: IconRenderer.tsx:28-68

The component tracks error state but only shows fallback. If an icon fails to load, there's no logging or debugging info.

Recommendation: Add optional error logging:

onError={(e) => {
  if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {
    console.warn('Failed to load icon:', icon.src, e);
  }
  setError(true);
}}

6. Documentation: No Migration Guide (Low Priority)

The PR description shows "before/after" examples, but there's no migration guide for users who want to add icons to existing servers.

Recommendation: Consider adding a brief migration guide in CHANGELOG or documentation about:

• How to choose appropriate icon sizes
• Best practices for icon hosting (CDN, data URIs, etc.)
• Security considerations for icon URLs

🧪 Testing Suggestions

The PR mentions no new unit tests were added. While the schema changes are straightforward, consider adding:

1. Type validation tests: Ensure icons array structure is validated
2. IconRenderer tests:
   • Test data URI rendering
   • Test error handling and fallback
   • Test with missing/invalid icons
3. Security tests: Validate URL schemes are restricted if validation is added
4. Integration test: Verify icons appear in inspector UI

📋 Minor Observations

1. Consistent comments: The icon documentation is copy-pasted across 4 files (tool.ts, resource.ts, prompt.ts, common.ts). Consider using JSDoc @see references to a single source of truth.

2. Type definition location: The Icon interface in IconRenderer.tsx:5-9 duplicates the one in common.ts. The component should import from the shared types instead.

3. ServerCapabilitiesModal complexity: The websiteUrl link logic at lines 137-148 is well-implemented with proper security attributes.

🎯 Summary

Overall Assessment: This is a solid implementation of SEP-973 with good structure and backwards compatibility. The main concerns are:

1. Security: Add URL validation to prevent potential attacks
2. Type Safety: Use more specific type assertions instead of as any
3. Icon Selection: Implement size-based icon selection as per the spec
4. Testing: Add tests for the new functionality

Recommendation: ✅ Approve with suggested improvements

The implementation is functional and safe to merge, but I strongly recommend addressing the security concerns (URL validation) before deploying to production. The type safety issues can be addressed when the SDK is updated.

📝 Action Items

If you'd like me to implement any of these suggestions, let me know! I can:

• Add URL validation helpers
• Implement size-based icon selection
• Add unit tests for IconRenderer
• Create a migration guide
• Add type guards for entity icons

Todo List

• Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md)
• Review type definitions and interfaces
• Review server implementation changes
• Review UI component changes
• Analyze type safety and error handling
• Check backwards compatibility
• Provide comprehensive feedback

needs to wait for the official sdk support

@tonxxd Would it be okay if I jump in and review this PR? I noticed a few areas where I can help with improvements.

@aryasoni98 the feature is not yet in the official sdk so for now it does not make sense to go forward, will reopen it once released